The Narrator is standing with his gun pressed against the cheek of Raymond K. Hessel, a convenience store clerk. Both the Narrator and the mechanic have to bring Tyler twelve driver's licenses to prove they made twelve human sacrifices. Raymond is crying uncontrollably as he squats on his knees. The Narrator looks through the contents of Raymond's wallet. He shows him a picture of his mother, asking him if these are his parents. This only upsets Raymond more. Among the other items in his wallet, the Narrator finds an expired community college student card.